Lyric

Sugar and milk, and you’re the honey

Hiding from the wind, where it isn't sunny

Sitting across from you, in our usual spot

Playing the "girlfriend," though I know I’m not

You’re drifting off, so I play a little game

Stirring in a cinnamon stick—you hate that, right?

Handing it over, wait for the light

Will you notice? Or will it stay the same?

Is it a blessing when things never end?

But deep in my head, I know we haven't begun

Is this just a circle that we’re meant to run?

Just a "best friend," or more than a friend?

The Cocoa Pact—I made it up on my own

And you’ll just nod kindly, with that gentle tone

Yeah, you’ll just nod kindly, like you’ve always known

Is this a farce? A play on a stage?

You shake your head kindly, turning the page

You smile so sweetly, while I’m in this cage

When I try to leave, you ask me to stay

Don’t give me hope in that casual way

"It’s just the cold," I tell my heart

Stay calm, be cool, don't let it fall apart

It’s the height of futility, asking you again

Searching for the answer I want from my friend

Will you catch on? Will you see through the veil?

Or will this quiet confession always fail?

Is it a blessing when nothing ever changes?

I’m losing my nerve, getting cold feet again

Should I stay here, or should I let it end?

The distance between us constantly ranges

The Cocoa Pact—I made it up on my own

And you’ll just forgive me, with that gentle tone

Yeah, you’ll just forgive me, while I’m all alone

Are you pretending to be oblivious and blind?

You won’t shake your head, you’re just being kind

You smile so sweetly, leaving me behind

If we give it a name, it finally exists

A bitter-sweet bond in the morning mists

I want to add just one more scoop of sugar to the cup

Will you go along with me?

Will you finally look up?

In every sense of the word

The Cocoa Pact—I want to grow it with you

Until you nod slowly, and say that it’s true

Until you admit what we’re going through

It’s sweet and it’s bitter, it’s warm like the sun

Stirring these days until we are one

The Cocoa Pact has only begun

Stirring it up

A little more sugar

Wait, you noticed the cinnamon, didn't you?